Recovery approaches

12-Step and SMART Recovery in Supported Housing

There is no single recovery approach that suits everyone. Both 12-Step fellowships and SMART Recovery can offer valuable support, and each comes with real strengths and limitations.

Mutual aid About 4 minutes

The 12-Step approach

Alcoholics Anonymous, Narcotics Anonymous and Cocaine Anonymous offer regular meetings and access to a large, established recovery community. Their programmes encourage honesty, personal responsibility, mutual support and helping others.

Advantages

  • Meetings are widely available and free.
  • Residents can build a support network outside the house.
  • Sponsorship provides continuing one-to-one peer support.
  • The programme offers structure and a clear path to follow.
  • Helping newcomers can strengthen the helper's own recovery.
  • Support can continue long after a person leaves supported housing.

Limitations

  • References to God or a Higher Power put some people off before they give it a chance, even though the fellowships do not require a particular religious belief.
  • Some residents do not identify with the language or culture of 12-Step meetings.
  • The fellowships are abstinence-based. This is consistent with OHC's requirements, but it may not suit someone seeking moderation or harm reduction.
  • The quality and atmosphere of meetings vary from group to group.
  • Turning up to a meeting is not the same as engaging with it.

SMART Recovery

SMART Recovery uses practical tools drawn from psychological approaches. It helps people examine their thinking, manage urges, solve problems and build a more balanced life.

Advantages

  • The approach is secular and does not involve a Higher Power.
  • It teaches practical techniques residents can apply to everyday situations.
  • It encourages self-management and personal choice.
  • The language can feel more accessible to people uncomfortable with addiction labels.
  • It can help residents see the links between their thoughts, feelings and behaviour.

Limitations

  • Face-to-face meetings are not as widely available as 12-Step meetings, although online SMART meetings provide another way to take part.
  • SMART does not offer an equivalent to long-term sponsorship, so someone wanting continuing one-to-one peer support may need to build this separately.
  • Its structured, tool-based format may not suit people who prefer more open-ended sharing or a less formal meeting.
  • Its main focus is on the present and future. Someone who needs to explore trauma or their personal history may also benefit from counselling or other professional support.

How this affects supported housing

Supported housing needs more than a rule requiring residents to attend meetings. People need opportunities to build relationships, practise recovery skills and develop support that will still be there when they move on.

A 12-Step approach can build a strong culture of fellowship, accountability and service. SMART Recovery can provide practical tools for managing thoughts, emotions and urges. The two are not rivals, and some residents benefit from elements of both.

Making either approach compulsory carries a real risk. Compulsory attendance can produce resistance, passive compliance or residents simply telling staff what they want to hear, none of which is recovery. Offering no structure at all carries the opposite risk, leaving people isolated and more vulnerable to relapse. The task for a house is to hold both of those risks in mind rather than default to either one.

Our approach at Open Hands Coventry

We give residents a genuine choice of recovery method: Twelve Step meetings, SMART Recovery or counselling. We do not impose one method over another. This choice concerns how residents support their recovery; OHC remains abstinence-based.

What we ask of every resident is the same regardless of which path they follow: they remain abstinent from alcohol and non-prescribed drugs, take prescribed medication as directed and engage seriously with their own recovery.

Neither 12-Step nor SMART Recovery can do the work for someone. Both can provide a real framework for change. Our job is to help each resident find the approach that works for them, and to support them in using it properly rather than just attending it.

← Back to Resources